Review: First Impressions: Emma Fox Classic Dome Satchel

I have been trying to find the perfect travel carryon for what feels like my entire adult life.

  • The eggplant purple soft duffel that came with my luggage set is just too ugly. The small one with wheels broke years ago.
  • My reversible navy/white striped beach tote is cute, but is too small and has no secure closure.
  • My giant black and white tote is big enough, but has no secure closure – seriously! the gaping opening is saying “look at me!” to the nearest thieves and pickpockets.
  • My work/laptop bag looks great and has plenty of pockets, but has no extra room for clothing storage.

So I’ve been looking around the internet for a while, reading reviews, looking at pictures, and calculating sizes. I checked and Our couch and rug came from overstock and my work tote came from ebags, so I knew the reviews on the sites were reliable. But nothing really made me click “checkout”.

My primary considerations were as follows:

  • real leather (brown or black were acceptable to me, colors or fake leather were not)
  • generally classic style so I could use it for years
  • secure closure (to prevent thieves)
  • outside pocket for easy access to boarding pass
  • small enough to walk down airplane aisles easily
  • large enough to fit 3-7 days worth of clothing
  • price range between $50 and $150

I was running out of places to look online, and running out of time to order it before my trip to St. Kitts. So today I decided to pop on over to Marshall’s while on my lunch break. I’ve had decent success buying leather items from Marshall’s before (the softest leather gloves, durable brown leather riding boots), so it was worth a try.

After looking at pretty much every bag they had (they were organized by color, but not by size, brand, price, or any other useful criteria), I just started feeling around with my hands. If my eyes couldn’t differentiate between 50 different black bags, perhaps my hands could.

As soon as I started paying attention to how the bags felt in my hands, instead of what they looked like, the selection appeared entirely differently. Some of them just felt cheap, like the fake leather would crack the first time I used it. Others were more of a coated canvas material, which I knew I didn’t want.

But then I felt something entirely different.


It was soft, supple, and smooth under my fingertips. If the other bags felt like polyester or plastic, this one felt like cashmere. I immediately pulled it out from behind 4 other bags, and took it out to get a better view.

I had found what I was waiting for! I couldn’t stop running my fingers over the leather – it felt so comfortable and well-worn despite being brand new. Honestly I wish there were a way to convey texture through the internet because you wouldn’t believe how good this leather feels!

The inside had a bright and cheery pattern, and the outside had a few well placed metal accents. I wasn’t exactly thrilled with the price tag, at $169, but my fingers were doing all the deciding at that point. I bought it after double checking their return policy (30 days with the receipt), and I did some further comparison research to check the price. Macy’s lists the original price at $358 and the sale price at $268Loehmann’s is selling the red version for $209.99. Suddenly I don’t feel so bad about $169.

The size is perfect. The straps are long enough that the top of the bag sits between my elbow and my waist (I have a shorter torsoe than the figure in the image), so I would feel it if anyone tried to sneak in through the top of the bag. The bottom of the bag sits right around my hip. I can easily fit a three-day-weekend of bulky winter clothes, or a week+ of lightweight summer clothes in the bag. Most of my shoes are flats or flip-flops, so I could easily fit a couple pairs in the bottom without the bag bulging.

Initial verdict? Highly recommended. Also highly recommended by the random lady that came up to me in the store to say she had the same bag and LOVED it. I asked her about durability, and she said she hasn’t had any trouble with scratches or anything since she’s owned it (she has the red version).

I’ll be packing over the next couple weeks, in preparation for my trip, and I’ll post a final review once I get back. But after feeling the softness of this leather, the bag would have to grow legs and walk away in the airport for me to give it a negative review right now!

Do you have any awesome finds at stores like Marshall’s, TJ Maxx, or similar retailers? Tell me about them!

Categories: Fashion, Luggage, Review: Fashion

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

7 replies

  1. Congrats! Having the right gear is so important, especially in Europe. Depending on what airlines you fly, carry-on baggage restrictions are much stricter overseas than in the in the U.S. Be sure to do your research ahead of time, and never assume that what works on Delta will work on RyanAir. It’s often very pricey if you don’t comply with the rules.

    • You are right, the restrictions are much more strict! From what I can gather, the strictest standard is 55cm x 40cm x 20cm (21.6″ x 15.7″ x 7.8″). Luckily this bag clocks in at 17″ x 14″ x 4″, so I should be good regardless of what airline I travel. The biggest thing for those budget airlines (RyanAir, etc) is that you are only allowed one carryon, rather than one carryon plus one purse/personal bag like you can do in the US. I’ll have to make sure my purse fits inside this bag!

  2. Awesome bag…what cannot be found by popping over to Marshall”s!

  3. Having the right carry-on can truly make traveling more pleasant – congratulations on finding this really lovely bag.


  1. Packing List: Caribbean 2012 « wander one day
  2. What You Require To Know About Carry-On Bags And The Airport

Let me know what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Steve McCurry's Blog

Steve's body of work spans conflicts, vanishing cultures, ancient traditions and contemporary culture alike - yet always retains the human element.

Sour Mango

My life in photos and other ramblings

A European Summer

A fine site


Putting my creative self to work through pictures


A Travel Blog - Traveling the World and Doing Good

nicole marie richardson


Ming Thein | Photographer

reframing the world one picture at a time

Liberated Traveler

Here to educate, motivate, and liberate.

Travel Geek Mag

Global. Culture. Captured.

(pre) concept - break your journey

On travel and Photography

%d bloggers like this: